Jean Anthelme Brillat-Savarin on the Art of Breakfast
© 2025, T Flanigan
“All rights reserved”
EPUB, PDF
This is the First Edition Of this Collection
Contribution by Charles T. Geppert
All necessary disclaimers are hereby invoked for CMA purposes
To all our Discerning Readers, who have come to Indulge themselves, not in the preparation of the meal itself, nor in order to gain a Glimpse of Any Receipts for the meals, but to Vicariously Participate, along with the Critic, in the repast.
Epigraph
“The discovery of a new dish confers more happiness on humanity than the discovery of a new star.”
— Jean Anthelme Brillat-Savarin
Preface by the Editor
In presenting to the public these recovered meditations of Jean Anthelme Brillat-Savarin, it is necessary to offer both apology and explanation. The apology is for the temerity of publishing a work so wholly unpractical; the explanation, for the manner in which it was obtained.
It is known to all readers of discernment that the illustrious author of La Physiologie du Goût departed this world in the year of grace 1826. Yet the philosopher’s appetite for observation appears not to have perished with his body. Through what agency his spirit has been permitted to revisit the breakfast-tables of the twenty-first century, I shall not presume to define. Whether by dream, séance, or some subtler commerce of the imagination, he has been seen—at least by this editor—seated once more before a modest repast, his pen poised between reflection and indulgence.
These pages are the fruit of that improbable encounter. I have ventured only to arrange his musings, to translate where necessary, and to suppress certain digressions on the character of contemporary toasters which, though learned, were too vehement for polite publication. Otherwise the thought and flavour remain his own.
Readers who seek in cookery a catalogue of receipts will find little nourishment here. The present volume does not teach how to prepare a breakfast, but how to deserve one. Its concern is less with the chemistry of ingredients than with the moral alchemy by which appetite becomes gratitude. To eat, says our author, is to participate in civilisation; to breakfast well is to reaffirm one’s place within it.
The essays that follow treat of our common morning fare—avocado, bacon, eggs, coffee, toast and its several accompaniments—with the gravity which the frivolous often deserve but seldom receive. Each dish is examined as though it were a principle, each utensil as though it carried an ethic. There are moments of humour, for philosophy must smile if it is to digest, yet beneath the smile lies an unshakable conviction: that man, by refining his pleasures, refines himself.
Should the modern reader, distracted by haste and invention, find in these pages a pause, a chuckle, or the faint remembrance of civility, the editor’s labour will not have been in vain. For amid all the revolutions of taste and technology, one truth abides—that the first meal of the day is the truest mirror of the soul that greets it.
And now, with due reverence to the immortal author, the table is laid, the coffee poured, and the reader invited to breakfast.
—The Editor
On the Sublime Mystery of Avocado Upon Toast
Of tranquillity, fruit, and civilisation before noon
I. The Prelude of Curiosity
It was in the course of my observations upon the infinite refinements of the table that I first encountered a certain modern preparation, modest in appearance yet provocative in reputation. They called it avocado upon toast — a phrase which to my ear had the ring of rusticity, yet was spoken by city men with the same reverence once reserved for truffles or champagne. I resolved to inquire whether this new enthusiasm were mere fashion or true discovery; for even in the smallest dishes there often lies concealed an entire philosophy of pleasure.
II. Of the Fruit and Its Character
The avocado — a fruit unknown to the kitchens of my youth — presents itself with the hauteur of the exotic and the heart of the domestic. Beneath its sombre robe of green lies a flesh as smooth as satin and as docile as a well-tempered thought. It does not seek to dazzle the palate, but to console it. Its flavour, neither sweet nor savoury, seems suspended between categories, and for this very reason it marries all things.
There is in it a tranquillity, a calm voluptuousness, that no other fruit possesses. The peach seduces, the strawberry teases, but the avocado persuades. It is the diplomat of the vegetable kingdom.
III. Of the Toast and Its Office
The bread, meanwhile, serves as the stage upon which this tranquil performer may display its charms. But not any bread will do. It must be of noble grain, sufficiently firm to bear the weight of its companion, yet tender enough to yield beneath the knife. The toasting of it is an act of devotion: the fire must kiss, not consume. One must seek that precise instant when the crust is coloured like old gold and the crumb exhales the faint perfume of warmth.
In this alliance of fruit and fire there is a lesson for all lovers — that harmony is born not of similarity but of contrast.
IV. Of Garnishes and Heresies
There are zealots who would crown this union with poached eggs, others who scatter upon it the crimson of chili, or the ivory of cheese. Let them do so; every nation and every appetite must express itself. Yet I maintain that the purest form of this dish requires but three accomplices: salt, lemon, and leisure.
The salt awakens, the lemon brightens, and leisure — ah, leisure — permits the senses to listen. Without that last ingredient, even the richest fare becomes a vulgarity.
V. Of Its Moral and Philosophical Significance
Those who mock this delicacy as a caprice of the idle have not understood its meaning. For in avocado upon toast one beholds the victory of refinement over haste. It is the breakfast of contemplation. The man who prepares it must cut with gentleness, season with restraint, and eat with attention. In so doing he performs, though he knows it not, an act of civilisation.
When I behold a youth seated before such a plate, sunlight on his shoulder and serenity on his brow, I am inclined to forgive the century its machines and its noise. For while there remains one soul capable of tasting with reverence, mankind has not wholly abandoned the art of living.
VI. Aphorism
Tell me what you eat upon your morning bread, and I shall tell you the degree of your enlightenment.